Free express shipping over $99 GRA & IGI certificates Quote in 1 business day

Journal / Moissanite Vs Diamond

Moissanite Insurance Appraisal Gap
HOLYCOME / NOTESMoissanite Vs Diamond  ●  9 November 2026  ●  8 MIN

Moissanite Insurance Appraisal Gap

A buyer in Austin insured a 1.2 ct moissanite ring for $6,800 because the appraisal form had a diamond box ticked by habit. Two years of premiums later she asked what the policy would actually replace.

The gap between an insured value and a replacement cost is the gap between a premium and a claim, and it is the most common appraisal error in the moissanite market.

[1]Why the gap exists

Appraisal forms are built around diamonds, so the replacement cost field is often filled from a diamond price list even when the stone is moissanite. The form looks complete and the number is wrong by a factor of eight to twelve.

An insurer prices a policy against the stated value, so the premium follows the inflated number. The claim, when it comes, is settled against the same stated value and the replacement is bought at the market price for the same stone.

StoneRetailInsured atPremium
Moissanite 1.2 ct$420$420Base
Moissanite 1.2 ct$420$6,80016x base
Lab diamond 1.2 ct$1,300$1,3003x base
Natural 1.2 ct$6,800$6,80016x base

The premium difference is the cost of insuring a number rather than a stone. It is paid every year and it never returns.

Emerald cut moissanite solitaire ring with a wide table on white

[2]What an appraisal must state

Five fields: the stone type, the stone's measurements in millimetres, the carat weight, the metal and karat, and the replacement cost for that specific combination.

The stone type is the field that decides everything after it. An appraisal that says white stone with a weight but no type is an appraisal an insurer will read as a diamond until told otherwise.

The measurements field

Measurements matter because they fix the stone's size independently of the weight. A 6.5 mm moissanite is a 1 ct equivalent, and the replacement has to match the millimetre size rather than the carat label.

An appraisal with measurements lets a replacement be sourced without a second visit to the jeweller. An appraisal without them sends the claim back to the bench for a re-measure.

[3]How a policy is written

Three common structures: agreed value, replacement cost and actual cash value. Agreed value pays the stated number, replacement cost buys a like piece, and actual cash value pays the depreciated amount.

Moissanite sits best under replacement cost with a stated stone type, because the replacement is cheap and the dispute is about what the piece was rather than what it is worth.

The deductible question

A $200 deductible on a $420 ring makes the policy close to pointless for a single-item claim, and it is still worth having for a theft that takes the whole collection.

Buyers usually insure the collection rather than the piece, which changes the maths: one deductible against five rings is a reasonable structure and one against a single ring is not.

[4]The appraisal that gets disputed

Three failures: a stone type left blank, a replacement cost copied from a diamond list, and a photograph that does not show the setting. Each of those gives an insurer a reason to re-value at claim time.

The photograph matters because the setting is half the replacement cost on a moissanite piece. A ring photographed from the top only cannot be re-made, and the claim becomes a negotiation about the mounting.

The certificate link

An appraisal should reference the certificate number and the laboratory. That link lets an insurer confirm the stone without a bench visit, which is the difference between a claim paid in weeks and one paid in months.

[5]What a buyer should ask

Four questions: what stone is named on the form, what the replacement cost is based on, whether the setting is described, and whether the certificate number is on the page.

A jeweller who cannot answer the first question in one sentence has filled the form from habit rather than from the piece.

[6]What we do

We issue appraisals that name moissanite, give millimetre measurements and the certificate number, describe the mounting and quote a replacement cost for the same stone. Buyers who need a diamond-comparable number are told the two numbers separately.

Minimum order is 50 pieces per design and sizes can be mixed. Sample lead time is around 20 days from approved CAD, bulk 25 to 30 days, and stock designs ship in 15 to 20 days under 500 pieces. Payment is a 30 percent deposit with the balance before shipment, by T/T, PayPal or Western Union.

[7]How a claim actually runs

A claim starts with a call, then a form, then a request for the appraisal and the certificate. The insurer compares the stated replacement cost with a market quote for the same stone, and that comparison is where most moissanite claims slow down.

A claim with a stone type, a millimetre measurement and a certificate number moves to a quote in days. A claim with a weight and a photograph of the top of the ring moves to a bench visit, and the bench visit is scheduled weeks out.

The practical point is that the appraisal is written once and read twice: once at purchase and once at claim. Everything that speeds the second read should be on the first page.

[8]What a re-make costs against a replacement

A replacement buys the same stone and a comparable mounting. A re-make copies the buyer's specific design, which is a bench job and priced by the hour rather than by the piece.

The difference matters when the design is custom. An insurer will pay for a comparable mounting and not for a hand-carved crest, unless the appraisal states the mounting as a custom piece with its own value.

A buyer with a custom moissanite ring should have the mounting appraised separately from the stone, because the two are replaced by different processes at different prices.

[9]The collection policy structure

Five rings on one policy share one deductible and one premium schedule, which is cheaper than five separate policies and slower to settle on a single small item.

The trade is worth making when the collection's total exceeds the deductible by a wide margin. It is not worth making when one ring is the whole collection, because the deductible eats the claim.

A schedule listing each piece with its stone type and measurements belongs with the policy, and it should be updated when a piece is sold or replaced rather than at renewal.

[10]The appraisal cycle

An appraisal should be refreshed every three to five years, because replacement cost moves with metal and stone prices. A 2021 appraisal on a gold mounting is understated in a higher gold market.

The refresh is cheap and it prevents the claim being settled at an old price. It also catches a piece that has been repaired in a way the appraisal does not describe.

A buyer who has re-set a stone should re-appraise immediately, because the mounting on the policy no longer exists in the form it describes.

[11]The appraiser who never sees the stone

An appraisal written from an order sheet rather than from the stone is an appraisal with a borrowed number. It happens when a jeweller sells a ring, then fills a form from the invoice, and the invoice describes the piece in the seller's words rather than in a measurement.

The measurement is the difference. A stone measured at 6.52 mm and a stone described as 1 ct are the same stone until a replacement has to be sourced, and then only the measurement is useful.

A buyer can check this in ten seconds: if the appraisal has no millimetre field, the appraiser did not measure the stone.

[12]Why the metal matters to the insurer

Gold is recoverable, so an insurer can value a mounting against the metal market on the day of the claim. A silver mounting has almost no recoverable value, and the claim is priced as a labour cost rather than as a material one.

That is why a 14K mounting attracts a higher insured value than a silver one of the same design, and why the difference is larger than the metal's price suggests. The labour to re-make the mounting is the bulk of the number.

A buyer choosing between silver and gold on a moissanite piece should treat the difference as an insurance and re-sale difference as well as a wear difference.

[13]What the policy excludes

Three exclusions catch moissanite owners: gradual wear, a stone that loosens or falls out without an impact, and damage from a repair done elsewhere. All three are process risks rather than accidents.

A prong that loosens over a year is wear, not a loss, and the insurer will decline it. A stone that falls out after a bench re-tip at another shop is a repair risk, and the policy will ask who did the work.

The answer is maintenance: a prong check every year, a re-tip at the original bench, and a photograph of the setting at each service. That record is what turns a wear dispute into a documented claim.

[14]Frequently Asked Questions

Should a moissanite ring be insured?

Yes, at its own replacement cost. Insuring it at diamond retail pays a premium for a value that will not be claimed.

What should an appraisal say first?

The stone type. Everything else, including the replacement cost, follows from whether the stone is moissanite, lab diamond or natural diamond.

Does a certificate lower the premium?

It does not change the premium much, and it shortens the claim. An insurer who can verify the stone without a bench visit settles faster.

Is agreed value better than replacement cost?

For a single moissanite ring, replacement cost is simpler. Agreed value suits a collection where the total is stable and the pieces are hard to re-make.

[15]Next step

Send the stone's measurements and the mounting description, and we will issue an appraisal that names the stone and the replacement cost. See moissanite work in the archive, read the journal on resale value, or open a brief on the contact page.

Ready when you are

Send a photograph. Get the price tomorrow.

Request a quote WhatsApp us

MOQ for a single commission is 1 piece; wholesale MOQ is 20 pcs per style. Sampling takes 7-14 days, bulk 15-25 days after CAD approval. Payment is T/T with a 30% deposit, balance before shipment; PayPal and major cards are accepted.

Every piece passes a quality check before dispatch, and authenticity is matched to its certificate, with a return policy and repair service after delivery. Our in-house jewelers and artisans have years of experience setting moissanite and lab-grown stones from responsible, traceable suppliers; customer reviews and commission testimonials are shared in our journal and on the about page. Questions? Email service@holycome.com or WhatsApp +86 13377447107.

WhatsApp us Get a quote
WhatsApp Email