Journal / Jewelry Care
Jewellery Repair Policy for Bulk Buyers
A distributor in Dallas offered a lifetime repair guarantee on a 400 piece order and spent more on repairs in year one than the margin on the whole order. The policy had no exclusions and no time limit.
A repair policy is a cost line, and it has to be priced and bounded like any other cost line.
[1]The three repair classes
Repairs divide into plating and refinishing, resizing, and setting work. Each has a different cost driver and a different failure cause, so each needs its own policy line.
| Class | Typical cost | Cause |
|---|---|---|
| Replate | Low per piece | Normal wear |
| Refinish | Low per piece | Scratches, wear |
| Resize | Medium per piece | Size change |
| Setting repair | Medium to high | Loose or broken setting |
| Stone replacement | Stone cost plus labour | Impact or loss |
The last two rows are where a policy without limits becomes expensive, because stone replacement carries the stone cost rather than a labour charge.

[2]What to cover
A defect in manufacture is the seller's cost. A wear event is the buyer's or the end customer's cost. The line between them is the policy, and it should be written rather than implied.
Manufacturing defects: a broken solder joint, a prong that was never tight, a plate that failed adhesion rather than wear, a stone that arrived loose. Those are covered without a time limit that expires before the defect shows.
What wear looks like
Wear is gradual, symmetrical and at the points of contact. A plate that wears thin at the shank is wear; a plate that peels in a patch is adhesion failure. The distinction is visible under a loupe and it decides who pays.
[3]What to exclude
Three exclusions keep a policy affordable without making it unfair: damage from impact, damage from chemicals, and work done by a third party.
A customer who wears a ring in a pool and returns it with a pitted surface has caused the damage. A customer who has a local bench resize a ring and then returns it for a plating failure has introduced a variable the seller cannot control.
A fourth exclusion belongs in writing for plated goods: wear at the high points after the stated interval. That is not a failure, it is the plate reaching the end of its designed life, and the policy should say so before the claim arrives.
The time limit
A plating guarantee should run for the interval the plate thickness supports, which is 12 to 24 months for a 1 micron plate. A guarantee longer than the plate's life is a guarantee that will be claimed.
[4]Pricing the policy
A repair allowance is simpler than a guarantee. The buyer sets aside a percentage of the order value, and the allowance covers a fixed number of replates and refinishes per piece.
A 3 percent allowance on a 400 piece order funds roughly one replate per piece, which is the realistic claim rate for plating wear over two years. A policy priced above that is a policy that pays for damage rather than wear.
The allowance should be recalculated from the claim log at each reorder rather than carried forward as a fixed percentage. A design that generated 8 percent claims should not be sold with a 3 percent allowance for another two years.
The paperwork
Every repair needs a record: the piece, the fault, the cause and the charge. Without that record the next order is priced the same as the last one, and the policy never gets corrected.
[5]Resizing and ring construction
A resize is limited by the band, not by the bench. A plain band resizes two sizes in either direction; a channel set band resizes one; an eternity band cannot resize at all without remaking the setting.
A policy that promises free resizing without stating the band limits promises something the construction cannot deliver. The limit belongs in the policy as a condition rather than as an exception discovered at the bench.
What resizing costs
Marching, soldering and refinishing, plus a re-plate if the ring was plated. That is three bench steps for a two size change on a plated band, which is why resizing is priced higher than a polish.
On a channel set band the resize also moves the stones at the joint, which is a fourth step. That is the reason channel bands are usually resized one size rather than two.
[6]Setting repair
A prong that has loosened is a ten minute bench job. A prong that has broken at the base is a rebuild of the head. A bezel that has opened is a re-burnish of the wall.
The three cases price very differently and all three arrive described as the stone is loose. The policy should be priced by the repair rather than by the complaint.
The diagnostic step is a loupe check of every seat before any work starts. A ring with three loose prongs is a setting that was never correct, and it belongs in the defect category rather than the wear one.
When a stone is lost
A lost stone is the expensive case, because the replacement has to match the rest of the lot. Matching a melee stone is easy; matching a coloured centre stone after a year is not, and the policy should state that the replacement is matched as closely as the market allows.
[7]What the invoice should state
Four lines: the coverage period, the covered classes, the exclusions and the claim procedure. A customer who knows the procedure returns the piece through the right channel instead of through the retailer's inbox.
[8]Handling a claim in the first month
A claim in the first month is a manufacturing signal, and it should be handled differently from a wear claim. The first month questions are whether the setting was tight, the plate was continuous and the solder was full.
A first month claim rate above 2 percent means the process is producing defects rather than the customer causing damage, and the order should be reviewed rather than repaired piece by piece.
What to ask for
Two photographs and one sentence: where the fault is, and what the customer was doing when it happened. That is enough to classify the claim into defect, wear or misuse, which decides who pays.
[9]What a repair log reveals
A log with 100 entries sorted by fault type shows the design's weak points faster than any inspection. Ten prong failures in one design mean the prong is too thin, and the next order should change the prong rather than the policy.
That is the real value of a policy: it generates the data that corrects the product.
[10]What we do
We state the plate thickness so the buyer can set a guarantee interval that matches it, and we separate manufacturing defects from wear in writing. Where a buyer wants a repair programme, we quote it as a service line rather than folding it into the piece price.
Minimum order is 50 pieces per design and sizes can be mixed. Sample lead time is around 20 days from approved CAD, bulk 25 to 30 days, and stock designs ship in 15 to 20 days under 500 pieces. Payment is a 30 percent deposit with the balance before shipment, by T/T, PayPal or Western Union, with volume pricing at 200 and 500 pieces.
[11]What the first claim teaches
The first claim on a new design names the weak point. A prong failure points at the prong, a plate failure at the contact area, and a sizing failure at the tolerance.
That information should change the next order rather than the policy. A design that generates claims is a design to correct, and a policy that absorbs the claims hides the correction.
A buyer who tracks claims by design rather than by month finds the weak point within two orders, which is faster than any inspection report.
[12]When a claim should not be paid
Three cases: a piece that was repaired elsewhere, a piece damaged by a chemical the care line named, and a claim after the stated interval on a wear item.
Those three are the claims that make a policy expensive, and they are also the claims a written policy can decline without argument. A policy without them declines the same claims by negotiation.
Declining a claim is a service event and it should be answered in writing with the reason and the price of the repair. A customer who receives that reply usually accepts it.
[13]Frequently Asked Questions
Should a bulk buyer offer a lifetime guarantee?
Rarely. A lifetime guarantee on plated goods outlives the plate, and the claims arrive after the margin is spent. A time limit matched to the plate is fairer and cheaper.
Is a loose stone a defect or wear?
A stone that arrives loose is a defect. A stone that loosens after a year of wear is wear, unless the prong was never seated correctly.
How much should a repair allowance be?
Around 3 percent of order value for silver and plated goods, which funds roughly one replate per piece over two years.
Can a third party repair void the policy?
Yes, and it should. Work by another bench changes the piece in ways the original maker cannot verify.
[14]Next step
Send the order mix and the wear profile, and we will quote the repair programme as a separate line. See service work in the archive, read the journal on plating thickness, or open a brief on the contact page.